DICKIE - CHAPTER 6

DICKIE – CHAPTER 6

In Chapter 6, Dickie discusses Aldrich’s theory on aesthetic perception. In Aldrich’s mind, the aesthetics of a work can be understood objectively, not subjectively when the work is shown in a specific fashion. He also argues that there are two types of perception: the ordinary and the aesthetic. Ordinary perception is used in science, not art. Dickie discusses his feelings about how an object can be perceived through a picture/diagram. The picture from above looks like a lampshade, and from below, looks like a tunnel. From this diagram, Dickie argues that there’s only one form of perception that leads to three aesthetic objects. Dickie seems to butt heads with Aldrich’s ideas and beliefs. In one example, Aldrich presents two objects that are seen as impressionistic: a skyline at sundown, and a snowflake. Dickie completely disagrees with this belief, and argues that focusing one’s eyes in a unique way does not justify one believing that the object has a special aesthetic mode of perception. He concludes the chapter by arguing that there is not a real justification for saying that a particular form of aesthetic perception exists for an object to reveal itself in. All in all, a very interesting chapter.

REACTION
This chapter was a very complex one. For one, Dickie and Aldrich seemed to butt heads constantly. Even though many high thinkers may have absurd and extremely left field ideas and thoughts, they still help contribute to the overall conversation/debate about the topic at hand. Dickie does make some valid points, as well. Like many other chapters in the book, I had to read it many times to simply scratch the surface. It will definitely sink in more over time.